On November 14, 2026, U.S. District Judge Noël Wise denied a motion to dismiss Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., allowing the lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron to proceed. The case was brought by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states. Wise found the complaint plausible under the standard for this stage of a case, not that the companies had colluded or were liable. (The court’s order)
A motion to dismiss tests whether a complaint plausibly states a claim. Here, the judge’s decision means the plaintiffs’ antitrust case can continue; it does not resolve whether their allegations are true.
Why the complaint cleared the dismissal stage
The complaint alleges that the manufacturers restricted supplies of conventional DRAM, shifted capacity toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and wound down DDR4 production in parallel. HBM is a specialized type of DRAM used for AI accelerators, while conventional DRAM serves other memory needs. The court considered the alleged supply restrictions, shifts toward HBM and DDR4 wind-down together with circumstances including alleged supply lockups, customer screening, capacity decisions and prior antitrust conduct.
The order did not treat every allegation as support for the plaintiffs’ theory. Wise did not rely on conference attendance or public statements to support the inference of a conspiracy, and treated the market’s concentrated structure as neutral. The defendants’ position, as summarized in the order, is that each company made independent decisions consistent with its own business interests.
Wise captured the court’s assessment of the combined allegations with this analogy:
“their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.” — U.S. District Judge Noël Wise, in the November 14 order
The next dates in the case
The order set December 7, 2026, as the deadline for the defendants’ answers. It scheduled the initial case-management conference for January 12, 2027, at 9:00 a.m.