New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago were weighing alternatives to Google Search, according to a November 18 report by The New York Times. The dispute centers on a practical constraint: Google announced administrator controls for K–12 student accounts, while the reported lack of an AI-free version of Search leaves schools choosing whether to enable Search with its AI features or use another provider. The three districts were considering options, not announcing completed migrations.

What Google’s controls change for K–12 accounts

Google announced on November 3 that Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search would be off for K–12 student accounts until school administrators explicitly enabled them. The company’s announcement describes a control over access to those services.

That is different from a separate setting to keep Google Search while removing its AI features. The New York Times reported that Google would not provide a chatbot-free version because AI is integrated into Search. For a district that wants students to use Google Search without those features, the reported choices do not include a dedicated AI-off version.

Why three districts weighed other search providers

New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago were considering alternatives, the Times reported on November 18. Their approaches differed. New York City declined Google’s student chatbot pilot and was researching five other AI tools for possible high-school use. Chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said the city would explore other search options if Google did not reconsider its position.

Chicago Public Schools asked Google for Search without AI and said it would seek other search solutions if the two sides could not reach an arrangement. Los Angeles Unified School District was also considering alternatives. The Times reported that Google’s education team had helped Los Angeles schools turn off AI Mode for students signed into school accounts at the start of the school year; the district’s technology chief said the default search provider could be changed quickly.

Other search providers and school controls

The New York Times named DuckDuckGo and Microsoft Bing as alternatives with options to disable AI-generated answers. Reason also named Brave and Ecosia. These are reported options, not district adoption decisions; each school system’s choice depends on the service and controls it wants to use.

Some districts were also using controls and filters to block AI in Search. Central R-3 in Missouri, which serves about 2,000 students, reportedly signed up for Lightspeed Systems software designed to block AI Overview and AI Mode. The Times also reported that some New York City parents found AI Mode accessible at home through student accounts, underscoring that school settings and a student’s access outside school can be separate concerns.

Parent advocates describe the dispute

FOX 32 Chicago interviews Cassie Creswell about parent concerns over Google’s school AI policy

In a FOX 32 Chicago interview, Cassie Creswell, executive director of Illinois Families for Public Schools, discussed parent concerns about Google’s school AI policy. Her comments represent an advocate’s perspective on the issue.

NBC News reported that parents and teachers protested outside Google offices in seven cities, including Chicago, on November 11. The demonstrations brought concerns about school control and student use of AI into public view.

Google said Guided Learning was globally available in Google Classroom starting November 3. It described the feature as guiding students through some questions step by step rather than going straight to an answer. Google separately said it planned to pilot Guided Learning in Search at selected U.S. schools later in November. The Classroom availability and the planned Search pilot are distinct product stages.