The UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) dismissed the PlayStation Store class action on November 17, 2026. It ruled that the claimants had not established their proposed market, Sony’s dominance in a relevant market or the alleged abuses. The case concerned digital PlayStation games and add-on content, and was brought on behalf of about 12.2 million people. The CAT’s judgment summary says the claim failed in its entirety.

The 20% figure was the claimants’ estimate of a counterfactual; the judgment turned on whether they established their case in court.

What did the lawsuit cover?

Alex Neill Class Representative Limited brought the claim against Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Limited, Sony Interactive Entertainment Network Europe Limited and Sony Interactive Entertainment UK Limited. The claimants alleged that Sony’s conduct around digital games and add-on content involved exclusive dealing, tying, refusal to supply, and excessive and unfair prices. The CAT’s summary describes claims under the Chapter II prohibition of the Competition Act 1998 and Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.

The case went to a 30-day trial held between March and May 2026. The CAT listed its judgment, [2026] CAT 86, on November 17.

Why did the CAT dismiss the claim?

The claimants proposed a market focused on digital PlayStation games and add-on content, excluding physical-game distribution. The CAT rejected that market definition and concluded that the claimants had not established Sony’s dominance in a relevant market. It also found that the alleged exclusionary and exploitative abuses had not been established. The CAT’s summary of the decision explains that the Tribunal considered physical games, the ability to use multiple platforms and cross-platform functionality as potential constraints on Sony’s pricing. It noted limits on cross-platform functionality for some periods and types of games.

Those findings address the claims and legal theories in this proceeding. They are not a general ruling on PlayStation Store prices in every market.

What did the claimants’ 20% price figure mean?

The claimants argued that digital-content retail prices would have been about 20% lower without the alleged conduct. The CAT said that counterfactual was not made out. The figure was the claimants’ estimate of an alternative scenario, not a measured price reduction.

The Tribunal also said the claimants had not established that Sony’s margin was excessive or, even if it were, that it was unfair.

What hearing is listed next?

The CAT case docket lists a consequential hearing for December 17, 2026, at 2 p.m.