The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit heard xAI’s appeal of California’s AB 2013 on November 18, 2026, in X.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591. Law360 and Startup Fortune described the three-judge panel as appearing skeptical. That was a characterization of oral argument, not a decision on the appeal.

The reported reaction at oral argument is context; the earlier injunction denial was the procedural fact reported to remain in effect.

What AB 2013 requires and why xAI challenged it

Startup Fortune described AB 2013 as requiring generative-AI developers to publish high-level summaries of their training datasets, rather than the datasets themselves. xAI argues that the disclosure requirement violates the First Amendment and could expose trade secrets, according to Startup Fortune’s account.

Law360 also reported that the panel cited Ninth Circuit decisions upholding disclosure laws concerning drug pricing and climate change.

Why the earlier injunction denial matters

A preliminary injunction is a court order that can pause enforcement while a case proceeds. In its November 19, 2026, report, Startup Fortune said a federal district judge had denied xAI’s request for one earlier that year and that the denial remained in effect during the appeal. The report said AB 2013 continued to apply as the appeal proceeded.