On November 19, 2026, Advocate General Laila Medina proposed that personal data users must provide, together with consent to commercial use, could count as payment under the EU’s Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. Her nonbinding opinion in Case C-643/25 concerns Facebook’s claim that its service was free; it is not the Court of Justice of the European Union’s ruling. The Court’s summary sets out the proposed test and its limits.
When could Facebook data count as payment?
Under Medina’s proposal, required data and consent for commercial use could count as payment when they have economic value and a definite link to the commercial practice at issue. Her reasoning is that commercial use of personal data can generate advertising revenue and help finance a service. Users retaining their data would not, by itself, prevent that use from being treated as payment.
The proposed boundary matters: the “free” description would remain possible when data are processed exclusively to provide the service or comply with legal obligations. The proposal concerns data required for commercial use, not every instance in which a service processes personal information.
The proposal leaves data-funded services possible; it addresses whether a service that requires data for commercial use can be described as free.
Would the proposal ban ad-supported services?
No. Businesses could still offer services in exchange for personal data. Medina’s proposal concerns how an offer is described when access requires data and permission for commercial use; it would not prohibit an ad-supported or data-funded business model.
What dispute prompted the opinion?
The case concerns Facebook’s EU registration page, which said “Facebook is and remains free” in February 2015. The German consumer organization Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband challenged the claim. Meta Platforms Ireland operated Facebook in the EU at the time relevant to the dispute.
Germany’s Federal Court of Justice referred the EU-law question to the CJEU. The CJEU interprets EU law, while the German court will resolve the underlying dispute after receiving that interpretation. The Court’s November 19 release said its judges were beginning deliberations and that judgment would follow later.
How do EU privacy and consumer rules fit together?
Medina’s opinion treats the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and consumer-protection rules as applying cumulatively. The GDPR governs data processing; the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive governs commercial representations such as describing a service as free.
The Court’s summary also refers to later EU rules on digital content and consumer rights as recognizing data-for-service business models. Those rules do not change the meaning of the 2005 directive that Medina was interpreting.